The Democracy Journal
Search Site
Get Involved
This form does not yet contain any fields.
    Support the PJRC

    Support the PJRC for continued original analysis on ending the wars, funding domestic priorities and preserving civil liberties.

    Make a contribution to benefit the PJRC now! 

    Conferences & Events

    Tom Hayden speaks in Port Huron, MI, in celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Port Huron Statement.

    Invite Tom Hayden to speak in your town! 



    Follow Tom


    Contact Us
    This form does not yet contain any fields.

      In Response to The End of Counterinsurgency

      The US Army-Marine Corps Counterinsurgency Field Manual.I was glad to see evidence-based realism in George Friedman's appraisal of counterinsurgency at Stratfor. Unfortunately, there seems to be a cult trying to resurrect the South Vietnam Phoenix Program – see the US Army-Marine Corps Field Manual and writings of David Kilcullen.

      The key to this revisionist military history is its placement of blame on politicians, anti-war groups and public opinion in the US, not the dubious premise that Vietnamese nationalism, backed by the Soviets and Chinese, could be defeated by a huge American force allied to a venal client regime.

      The lesson should be that counterinsurgency’s Achillies’ heel is its dependence on unpopular and client regimes. But I was surprised at the minimal nature of Friedman's proposed mission for combat troops; e.g. Small infantry or marine units to protect sea lanes, in the example given. I agree there could be such a role, but then what is the reason for sustaining a massive Pentagon budget, hundreds of bases, et cetera? It sounds as though America is turning into Gulliver.

      PrintView Printer Friendly Version

      EmailEmail Article to Friend

      Reader Comments

      There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

      PostPost a New Comment

      Enter your information below to add a new comment.
      Author Email (optional):
      Author URL (optional):
      All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.